Anyone had any good success with plastic/rubberized cases

Verizon has a good rubber case for the Incredible I like it they also carry screen protectors in a 3 pack

I have mine from VZW also and it fits perfectly.  I definitely recommend the ones they have in the store.

yes ebay has some in different colors i am ordering one soon

I really HIGHLY recommend buying the invisible shield for this phone, had it on my Dare and loved it, and now I have it on my Incredible.  It is probably one of the best things ever for any phone.  Most def. worth the $20.  You will never need a new one.  Had it on my Dare for over a year and you couldn't tell!

"..."ring in" the new year..."  no pun intended I suppose

PhantomSkinz will be having its’ last BIG sale for 2009 from Thursday, December 24th through Monday night, December 28th.  All “skinz” are available for purchase at 50% off MSRP.  To take advantage of this huge discount, just enter the discount code “holiday50” in the discount/coupon code box upon checkout.  As always, all Internet Cell Phone Skin orders will receive 2 kits in each order. 

I haven't heard of anyone complaining about the fit of the aftermarket cases for the Incredible. It is a pretty simple design.

I personally like the hard plastic cases. I bought 2 on ebay with matte finishes (one black and one blue lol) which helps prevent the phone from slipping out of your hands more so than the shiny style ones. The matte finish makes it kind of look like a rubberized case, but feels a lot more durable. Silicone has always just made any phone feel cheaper to me. Regardless, i love them, and they fit, protect, and look great!